Podcasting Buffalo

Abraham Benrubi: "Passion, Practice, Participation"

In the Season 2 premiere of Podcasting Buffalo, the crew welcomes actor Abraham Benrubi — affectionately known to many as “Santa” from Holiday Touchdown: A Bills Love Story. With a career spanning decades, Abraham is best known for his breakout role on ER, along with memorable turns in Parker Lewis Can’t Lose, George of the Jungle, Without a Paddle, Robot Chicken, and more.
 
Abe dives into his early career, the reality of sustaining consistent work in Hollywood, and why — even after years of success — he chose to return to acting classes to refine and reshape his craft. He shares invaluable advice for actors and filmmakers alike, including his now-legendary philosophy of the “3 Ps,” and delivers a passionate message about not waiting for Hollywood — but creating constantly, wherever you are.
 
The conversation turns to Buffalo’s creative momentum, with Abe praising Western New York’s crews, work ethic, and the undeniable passion of Bills Mafia. The crew highlights local gems like the Buffalo 48 Hour Film Project, Amazing Fantasy Fest, and the thriving WNY horror community — a genre space that fits perfectly with Abe’s creative roots.
 
An inspiring, grounded, and energizing kickoff to Season 2.

William Mattar: Commercials & Branding

This week, the Podcasting Buffalo crew welcomes William Mattar of William Mattar Law Offices for a special edition episode all about branding, marketing, and the power of reinvention. A true Buffalo icon, Bill shares how his creative commercials and unforgettable jingle turned his firm into a household name—and what it takes to build a brand that truly stands out.
From viral campaigns to staying relevant in a changing media landscape, this episode is packed with lessons on keeping your business authentic and memorable. And of course, we close things out with a bonus recast of the courtroom comedy classic My Cousin Vinny!

Road to the Actors Expo

This week, the crew kicks things off by talking about the iconic yearly William Mattar commercials—a Buffalo pop culture staple—and the honor Casting Buffalo has had in being part of them. From there, we dive into the importance of networking events for both cast and crew, and why the upcoming Casting Buffalo Actors Expo on Saturday, August 23rd is a must-attend for filmmakers and talent looking to grow their careers.
 
We’re joined in-studio by our first official female guest, Roselyn Kasmire—a local SAG actress who just landed a role in Michael Mailer’s Little Audrey after auditioning for a completely different part. We discuss the power of bold choices, the value of restraint, and how delivering one undeniable performance can leave a lasting impression that gets you cast—even if it’s not for the role you originally went for.
 
Finally, we break down the official 2025 Expo schedule, highlighting guest speakers Tom Fontana and Charlene Amoia, and exploring the can’t-miss workshops from Film Neighbor Network. From scoring fresh headshots to gaining production skills in the PA training course, this episode is your roadmap to making the most of this year’s Expo. We can’t wait to see you there!

William Fichtner

This week, the crew sits down with Buffalo native and acclaimed actor William Fichtner for an inspiring conversation on craft, career, and chasing the dream. With Kyle tuning in remotely from Las Vegas, Jordan takes the lead as we dive into Bill’s reflections on the value of preparation, believing in yourself, and staying dedicated to the work—even when the odds are uncertain.
We revisit Coldbrook, the heartfelt drama Fichtner directed and shot in Western New York nearly eight years ago, and explore his recent performance in Michael Mailer’s Cutman. The team also highlights the upcoming Casting Buffalo Actors Expo on August 23rd—an event Bill calls a top-tier opportunity for actors to connect, grow, and take the next step.
To close, Bill teases a potential return to Buffalo in 2026 with a new project on the horizon.

Breaking into SAG & Major League Recast

This week, the crew pays tribute to Buffalo legend Joe Giambra, whose legacy lives on through the “I Love You Buffalo” podcast theme. We also share behind-the-scenes stories from the set of the latest Bills-themed holiday movie, reflecting on how the energy of Bills Mafia inspired both cast and crew.
 
The team dives into the path to becoming SAG-eligible, breaking down the different routes to union status and clearing up common misconceptions from a casting director’s perspective. Kyle presents a scene from Sinners, spotlighting Ryan Coogler’s powerful use of background performers and visual storytelling. To wrap it all up, Peter leads the crew in a spirited recast of the beloved baseball comedy Major League—complete with fastballs, curveballs, and a few unexpected picks.

Keith Costumes & Remember The Titans Recast

This week, the crew is joined by costume designer Keith Nielsen, the creative mind behind more than a dozen holiday films—including A Biltmore Christmas and the upcoming Holiday Touchdown: A Bills Love Story, both filmed in Buffalo, NY. Keith shares his journey from Mozart in the Jungle to Hallmark favorites, highlighting how thoughtful design, historical research, and storytelling are woven into every wardrobe choice.
 
We dive into the collaborative relationship between casting and costumes, with Kyle reflecting on how Marshall and costume legend Ruth Carter helped inspire the creation of Casting Buffalo. Actors get valuable advice on why knowing your sizing, speaking up about comfort, and trusting the costumers’ expertise is essential to the process. Finally, “Keith Costumes” becomes “Keith Casting” as he joins the crew to recast Remember the Titans—and while Harry tries to play catch-up, he’s understandably distracted with Ryan Gosling on the mind. (Aren’t we all?)

Amish Activity, Expo Talk, & Speed Recast

This week, the crew shares behind-the-scenes stories from casting Paranormal Activity: Next of Kin, including the unique challenge of finding authentic Amish background talent—and how far casting directors will go for the real deal. We talk about the importance of actors staying ready and answering the call when opportunity knocks, and we dive into plans for the 2025 Casting Buffalo Actors Expo, reflecting on past highlights and what’s ahead.
Peter spotlights a scene from Clover featuring the late JJ Alfieri—an actor, producer, and passionate advocate for Buffalo’s film community. To wrap things up, the crew tackles a recasting of the ’90s action classic Speed, searching for today’s perfect duo to take the wheel from Keanu Reeves and Sandra Bullock.

Producer Andrew Gernhard & Christmas Vacation Recast

This week, the crew welcomes Andrew Gernhard of Synthetic Cinema International—producer, executive, and the driving force behind bringing Newport Christmas to Buffalo, NY. Andrew shares his journey from the world of B-horror films to producing beloved holiday hits for Hallmark, Netflix, and beyond. We dive into the potential of Buffalo as a growing film hub, discussing the importance of expanding both crew and talent bases to support a thriving local industry.
 
We also chat with Emily August, a background extra on Newport Christmas and a rising comedy writer/performer whose social media following is built on sharp wit and charm.
 
With more productions on the horizon—including a Hallmark film featuring the Buffalo Bills—what does a tentpole production mean for the Queen City? And as the industry continues to shift toward IP-driven content and AI tools, how might that impact filmmaking here at home?
 
To wrap it all up, Andrew joins Kyle, Peter, Harry, and Jordan for a fun and spirited recast of National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation—bringing his studio head perspective to the table, while the crew brings the creative heat.

Turtle Tales, Tarantino Tension & Ghostbusters Recast

This week, the crew reflects on their early industry experiences working on Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Out of the Shadows (2016) in Buffalo, NY. Kyle shares the pressure of safeguarding film footage and his surreal moment overseeing a stunt helicopter, while Harry recalls the camaraderie of lockups and the impact of filming in local neighborhoods.
We also dive into Buffalo’s 2025 film scene, with The Yeti wrapping production and Fred Olen Ray returning for another Christmas movie. Kyle breaks down a pivotal scene from Inglourious Basterds (2009), exploring how Quentin Tarantino’s masterful suspense blocking and camera work elevated Christoph Waltz’s unforgettable performance. And finally, we cross the streams to recast Ghostbusters (1984), with Jordan fully joining in to reimagine the iconic team of Venkman, Stantz, Spengler, and Zeddemore.
Tune in for behind-the-scenes stories, filmmaking insights, and a fresh take on cinematic classics!

On-Set Mentality, A “Dog Day” Deep Dive & Back to the Future Recast

This week, the crew dives into on-set mentality , breaking down the wild story of an actor who tried sneaking onto set as an extra. We discuss the importance of patience in the industry (“Hurry Up & Wait”), how to stay engaged during downtime, and why treating your job like a hobby can hold you back.
Harry leads a deep dive into Dog Day Afternoon (1975), analyzing Al Pacino’s gripping performance and Sidney Lumet’s masterful direction. Meanwhile, Jordan shakes things up with a Back to the Future (1985) recasting—who nailed it? See how Peter and Kyle wrestle with reimagining their all-time favorite film.
Tune in for insider film industry insights, career lessons, and a fresh take on classic cinema!